Accessibility Notice

Can’t find something? Please be patient as we are currently updating our website and, due to higher demand, experiencing some out of stocks.

The Best Spices for Mulled Cider

As temperatures fall, one of the coziest ways to drive the chill away is with mulled cider, or apple cider slowly simmered with spices until it brims with warmth-inducing tang.

While there are many, many recipes for mulled cider, it's no surprise that the main ingredients in all of them are the traditional "warming" spices—allspice, cinnamon and clove. These spices are known for their pungency and bite, perfect for cooking in a cold climate.

Other spices with similar flavor notes are often added to the mix, including cardamom pods, dried ginger, nutmeg, peppercorns and star anise. Most recipes also call for orange peel, either fresh or dried.

Mulling cider grew out of the medieval ritual of wassailing, or adding spices to cider and/or various alcoholic beverages as a way to chase away the dark and cold at year's end. (Mulled wine, first concocted by the ancient Romans, is still a wintertime favorite.) The wassail would be served out of a communal bowl, accompanied by singing and general merry-making.

Today, the communal bowl is definitely a no-go. But the scent of cider slowly mulling on the stove is still enough to make most anyone breathe deeply and sigh in contentment.

As with all spices, make sure your mulling blend is fresh—last year''s leftovers just won't have the same zing. You can break up the cinnamon sticks (vastly preferable to ground cinnamon) by placing them in a large zip-close bag and crushing them with a rolling pin or heavy pot.

Traditional Mulled Cider

1/2 gallon fresh, unfiltered apple cider

2 tbsp whole allspice

4 cinnamon sticks, crushed

2 tbsp whole cloves

2 tbsp finely chopped crystalized ginger (optional)

2 whole nutmeg

Zest of 2 oranges

Place all ingredients in a large saucepan over medium-high heat until the cider just begins to boil. (Putting the spices in a cheesecloth bag eliminates the need for straining later.) Reduce the heat, partially cover, and allow to simmer for 20 to 30 minutes. Best served warm.

Yields 8 cups 

Like this article? You’ll love our weekly newsletter
sign up here!

**These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.

RELATED ARTICLES